- You have items in your cart!
While the allure of soaring through the skies as an airline pilot is undeniable, it’s worth considering other highly skilled and rewarding professions. One such field is engineering, a cornerstone of innovation and problem-solving across countless industries. For those weighing their options, understanding the realities of an engineering career – from education and earning potential to work-life balance – can provide valuable insights. Let’s delve into the various facets of becoming an airline pilot vs engineer.
Unlike the often extensive training required to become an airline pilot, the path to becoming an engineer typically involves a more direct educational trajectory.
Most engineering roles require a bachelor’s degree in a specific engineering discipline (such as civil, mechanical, electrical, or software engineering). These Bachelor of Science (B.S.) programs are generally four years in length, meaning aspiring engineers can enter the workforce around the age of 22, directly after completing their undergraduate studies.
While a bachelor’s degree is often sufficient for entry-level positions, some engineers choose to pursue a Master of Science (M.S.) degree or related advanced studies. This additional 1-2 years of education can allow for specialization and career advancement.
It’s important to note that, unlike professions such as airline pilot, law, or medicine, there isn’t a universal licensing exam that all engineers must pass. However, certain specialized fields may require becoming a Professional Engineer (P.E.). This involves passing the Fundamentals of Engineering (FE) exam, gaining relevant work experience, and then passing the Professional Engineering (PE) exam. 1 Despite its importance in some sectors, many engineers, particularly in fields like software or electrical engineering, work successfully in the industry without a P.E. license.
In comparison to aspiring airline pilots, who may not always require a four-year degree but must accumulate minimum flight hours, the initial formal training period for engineers can be considerably shorter and more structured around academic study.
While that may be enticing to some, it may prove less alluring for those who appreciate the ever-changing nature of studying to be an airline pilot vs engineer.
The financial investment in becoming an engineer primarily centers on the cost of a four-year undergraduate education. The cost of flight training to become a pilot often ranges from $80,000 to $150,000 for a comprehensive zero-to-commercial pilot program.
The cost of engineering programs can vary widely by type of institution.
In addition to tuition, students must also factor in living expenses, which can add a substantial amount to the overall cost.
While many engineering students graduate with student loan debt, the average amount is often comparable to that of other bachelor’s degree holders in the United States (around $30,000 – $35,000). In some cases, engineering majors may incur less debt due to a higher likelihood of receiving STEM-related scholarships. Conversely, attending a high-cost institution can lead to a larger debt burden. Overall, a reasonable estimate for student debt upon graduating with an engineering degree falls within the $20,000 to $50,000 range, assuming no significant scholarships or family support.
When compared to the often substantial financial outlay required for flight training and potentially advanced degrees for pilots, the upfront educational costs for engineers are generally lower and more predictable. Furthermore, the absence of expensive professional schools or ongoing specialized training programs beyond a bachelor’s degree may contribute to a more manageable financial pathway.
An engineering degree is often cited as a strong return on investment. Graduates typically enter the workforce around age 22 with competitive starting salaries and a relatively lower burden of student debt, allowing for earlier financial independence. Some employers even offer tuition reimbursement for further education, such as a master’s degree pursued part-time.
The field of engineering encompasses a wide array of specializations, each with its own salary landscape. However, in general, engineering offers solid and competitive earning potential.
Entry-level salaries for engineers are among the highest for recent college graduates. In the mid-2020s, many bachelor’s degree holders in engineering can expect starting offers in the range of $65,000 to $80,000, with variations depending on the specific field and geographic location. For example, entry-level mechanical or civil engineers might start around $65,000, while electrical or computer engineers could see starting salaries of $75,000 or higher. Software engineers, often holding engineering degrees, can command starting salaries exceeding $100,000 at leading technology companies.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), the median wage for all engineers (across all experience levels) was approximately $91,420 in 2023. This indicates that many engineers reach the high five to low six-figure salary range by mid-career (around 10-15 years of experience), particularly those in technical lead or management roles, who might earn between $100,000 and $130,000. Certain specialized fields, such as petroleum engineering or specific roles within the tech industry, can offer even higher earning potential, while others, like civil engineering, might have a slightly lower average.
For engineers who remain in purely technical roles, salary growth may plateau in later career stages unless they transition into management. A senior engineer with over 20 years of experience might earn between $120,000 and $150,000 in many industries. Those who ascend to engineering management or executive positions can see significant increases in pay; the median wage for engineering managers was around $152,000 per the BLS in 2023.
In comparison, here’s a look at what airline pilots may expect to make throughout their careers:
Over a 40-year career, an engineer earning a median annual wage of around $91,000 could accumulate a gross income of approximately $3.6 million. However, with typical salary growth over time, many engineers will likely earn significantly more. Some analyses estimate lifetime earnings for engineers to be around $5 million by retirement. While this might be lower on average than the potential lifetime earnings of pilots, doctors, or high-end lawyers, it still represents a substantial multi-million-dollar career. Importantly, because engineers start earning earlier and with less debt, their ability to accumulate net worth through investments and homeownership can begin sooner.
Given the generally lower student debt and competitive starting salaries, engineers often can repay their undergraduate loans relatively quickly. Many graduates with, for example, $30,000 in debt and a $70,000 starting salary could potentially become debt-free within five years or less.
Paying off debt as an airline pilot vs engineer is quite comparable. A realistic timeframe for paying off flight training debt is 5 – 10 years, and some airlines offer tuition reimbursement to help offset the cost of training.
Engineering jobs generally offer a good work-life balance compared to some other demanding professions.
Most engineers work full-time, typically around 40-45 hours per week, with occasional overtime depending on project deadlines. Work schedules are usually stable, with less frequent all-nighters or regular weekend work compared to roles like airline pilot or doctor. While the specifics can vary by industry (e.g., a field engineer might have early mornings, while a tech startup engineer could experience periods of longer hours), the overall culture in engineering tends to respect employees’ personal time. Travel may be required in some roles, but many positions are primarily office-based with a predictable routine.
Stress levels in engineering can arise from complex technical challenges and tight deadlines, but it’s often a different type of pressure – more focused on problem-solving than emergency situations or adversarial conflicts. Many engineers find their work intellectually engaging without being overly stressful on a daily basis. Importantly, engineers generally have the ability to “leave work at work” outside of business hours, allowing for a better balance with family and hobbies. While burnout can occur, particularly in fast-paced tech environments, it is arguably less pervasive than in some other high-stakes professions.
In contrast to the potentially unpredictable schedules and high-pressure environments that airline pilots can face, engineering often provides a more stable and predictable work rhythm.
Engineering jobs are generally stable, although they can be influenced by industry cycles. Overall demand for engineers is strong, with projections indicating faster-than-average growth and numerous job openings each year. While the stability of specific engineering disciplines can vary (e.g., strong growth in software and environmental engineering versus potentially slower growth in some manufacturing roles), unemployment rates for engineers tend to be low.
Beyond the core aspects of education, salary, and work-life balance, there are other factors to consider when evaluating an engineering career.
In conclusion, the path to becoming an airline pilot offers the unique experience of flight and a potentially high-earning trajectory, while a career in engineering presents a grounded yet equally rewarding alternative. It typically involves a shorter and more predictable educational path with a strong return on investment, competitive salaries, a generally good work-life balance, and stable long-term career prospects. For individuals with an aptitude for math and science who enjoy problem-solving and innovation, choosing between airline pilot vs engineer might be a tough choice!